This is Part 2 of a 3-part series on legal problems that remain hidden. In Part 1, we talked about how many legal problems begin as a normal business decisions long before they appear as legal problems. Part 2 focuses on why the legal problems remain hidden.
In my experience, the issue is not normally “because company ownership does not care.” Quite the opposite. Ownership wants success, and it can only focus on so many priorities, so the focus is triaged to what is urgent. Customers want answers, employees want support, and those immediate operational questions tend to get priority. Contrast that with the legal problems covered in this series. Ownership arrangements, work product, and governance matters can hang out in the background for years. They do not usually interfere with operations, interrupt management meetings, or stop the company from serving its customers. Even though these legal problems can end up ultimately being incredibly important, it is understandable that the company would focus on operational issues that more easily grab attention, especially when nothing bad is happening.
The trouble is that “absence of urgency” can look a lot like “absence of risk,” and it can be hard to tell the difference. In ownership matters, there is usually a shared understanding about how much everyone owns, how decisions get made, and how to plan for the future. Those assumptions can have staying power with little obvious reason to revisit them because the company’s operations are not noticeably impacted. Suddently, the time comes for a sale, a new round of investment, or an owner retirement. It can be a similar story with work product.
Going back to the earlier example of hiring a contractor, once the work is done and the bill is paid, why wouldn’t the assumption of who owns the work product be settled? Like assumptions around ownership, these assumptions also have a tendency to hang around until an upcoming sale, investment, or IP dispute strike to the core of those assumptions.
That brings us back to the core question of this post: Why do legal problems stay quiet? Because the situation allowed them to stay quiet. When that situation changes in the form of an upcoming deal, ownership transition, IP dispute, or some other big event, the previously unchallenged assumptions all of a sudden meet their challenge. And that is what makes these hidden legal issues so tricky. That the issue isn’t obvious does not mean that it does not exist. It might just mean that nobody has had a reason to look closely. If a company waits until a big event to look closely, the risk is higher that it will find itself in a position where its assumptions are challenged when it will hurt the most. In the next post, we will focus on what to do to avoid unchallenged assumptions before the big events.
Thanks for reading!